Recently, bad practices caused a client’s accounts receivable to get extended well past 90 days. In fact, the client had 20% of its receivables dated further back than 120 days. Company staff knew that much of that would prove to be uncollectible, but no one really knew the extent of how bad it was.
At the same time, it was discovered that the billing and collections processes also had numerous flaws, and cash was leaking in several places before accounts even hit the accounts receivable department. A short-term loan had bridged a prior cash shortage, but now the loan was coming due. If the business were going to stay afloat, they would need to explore the option of seeking help from the lender directly.
A short-term loan had bridged a prior cash shortage, but now the loan was coming due.
While the situation had been brewing for over a year, and management had been given several warnings, the CEO still failed to get ahead of the problems. Ownership and the board had lost confidence in the management team. The company was out of cash and out of time, so the board engaged an outside consultant to help save the company.
The consultant quickly assessed the revenue forecast, collections process, cost structure and revalued the receivables. He also noted three things that needed to happen quickly:
For most private and family businesses, as long as the business is somewhat profitable, and the bank and the IRS are happy, there is no external pressure to force change. However, running out of cash, having the bank enforce covenants or receiving a call from the IRS will always drive change.
Lenders want to know that they will be paid back on time and with enough cushion to provide a margin of safety. While I hear of differing approaches to seeking help from the lender directly, I personally subscribe to the theory that no one likes surprises, and bad news does not get better with age.
You may also like, “How to Stay Afloat When You’re Swimming in Financial Debt”
It is important to be upfront and direct with the bank. Don’t avoid the issue, but rather own it and solve it. That means companies must show up with a plan that works for the bank and have a backup plan in case the facts change against their favor.
From a lender’s viewpoint, the most important judgment is the personal character of the borrower. Yes, you need to have collateral and meet covenants. After all, that creates good incentives and results in pain for non-performance. But, if the lender believes the borrower cares less about the lender than himself (i.e. selfish), then the bank is unlikely to provide a favor when the borrower really needs it.
From a lender’s viewpoint, the most important judgment is the personal character of the borrower.
In this case, the outside consultant recommended the following plan:
Next, the borrower needed to explain how the bank would get its money back, prove there was sufficient collateral, show a reasonable 13-week cash flow plan, and make it easy for the bank to just say “yes.”
The bank has no obligation to protect the owner’s interests. If the borrower does not bring a sound plan, along with a contingency plan, then the loan is likely to be moved to workout. The workout group exists to ensure that the bank recovers full value,not to fix the company. If you don’t give the bank a good plan that assures full recovery, then the workout group will. For this reason, borrowers are sometimes liquidated when the business could have been saved.
The bank has no obligation to protect the owner’s interests.
While never a pleasant situation to be in, companies can come out of workout stronger if they use the pain to shed extra costs, adopt good management practices and get competitive.
In the situation mentioned above, the story ends well. In order to show good character, the owner stopped taking any compensation before seeking help from the lender.
The consultant presented a plan that showed how the bank would get all of its money returned while maintaining enough collateral to keep the loan in compliance. A good, 20-year-old business was saved, along with hundreds of jobs.
You may also like, “Scary Word(s) No. 11 – Debt, Collateral, Covenants, Guarantees and More”
With the cost cuts, downsizing and reconfiguration completed ahead of the meeting, the bank just needed to see the numbers and confirm that the collateral was sufficient. In 24 hours, the borrower received the answer he needed to hear.
What about the backup plan in case the bank rejected the consultant’s recommendation? The consultant and owner located an investor who would inject capital on acceptable terms if failure was the only alternative. But they kept this fact to themselves, and never told the bank about it during the negotiations!
Seeking help from the lender should be considered as a viable option if you have the right plan in place.
When all was said and done, the bank extended the loans because it was in its own best interest to do so, not because it wanted to be nice. By cooperating, the bank was more likely to get repaid in good order, without taking the risk or expense of workout. Remember, banks like to lend money, not run their client’s businesses. Seeking help from the lender should be considered as a viable option if you have the right plan in place.
Bruce Werner is the Managing Director of Kona Advisors LLC and served as an outside director on private company boards for the last three decades. Kona Advisors LLC provides advisory services to the owners, investors and CEOs of private and family-owned businesses. With deep experience in governance, succession planning, finance, strategy and management issues, Kona…
Guidelines to Improve Banking Relationships (What Does Edgar Allan Poe Have to Do With It?)
Always Balance Family and Business in a Family Owned Business
Building the Best Strategy to Drive Cash Allocation
Designing Board Evaluations for Private Companies to Succeed
Effective Private Company Board Strategies Drive Goals to Completion
Effective Outside Directors Provide Leadership When It Is Needed Most
Please log in again. The login page will open in a new window. After logging in you can close it and return to this page.